From Mulligan recalling the scene “changed a million times” to creator Lee Sung Jin making a clutch last-minute dialogue swap, the team behind the Netflix hit tell all.

‘Madness’: Oscar Isaac, Carey Mulligan, and more behind *Beef *season 2 break down that wild premiere fight scene

From Mulligan recalling the scene "changed a million times" to creator Lee Sung Jin making a clutch last-minute dialogue swap, the team behind the Netflix hit tell all.

By Ryan Coleman

Ryan Coleman

Ryan Coleman is a news writer for with previous work in MUBI Notebook, Slant, and the LA Review of Books.

EW's editorial guidelines

April 16, 2026 10:00 a.m. ET

Leave a Comment

Oscar Isaac on 'Beef'. Credit:

Courtesy of Netflix

- *Beef* stars Oscar Isaac, Carey Mulligan, and Charles Melton, along with series creator Lee Sung Jin, are taking EW inside the epic fight scene that sets the stage for season 2.

- Mulligan describes the "big development process" that took "months" of discussion and prep before even getting to cameras, and then changed "millions of times."

- Lee describes the difference in younger and older perspectives on the real-life fight that inspired the scene as the show's "north star."

**This article contains spoilers about *Beef *season 2*.***

*Beef* season 2 is finally here. And it's beefier than ever.

Lee Sung Jin's Emmy-winning study of what happens when two people lock into a cycle of escalating revenge plays that can't easily be broken is now an anthology series. Season 2, which premiered on Netflix on Thursday, swaps original stars Steven Yeun and Ali Wong out entirely for a cast of couples. Oscar Isaac and Carey Mulligan play overworked country club manager Josh Martin and his under-stimulated wife Lindsay Crane-Martin, while Cailee Spaeny and Charles Melton play Ashley Miller, an underpaid employee of that club, and Austin Davis, her golden retriever boyfriend.

A lot's different this time around, from the upscale setting, to the continent-hopping storyline, to the heartfelt exploration of love and relationships. But it all starts the same, with a big, blistering beef.

Lee, Isaac, Mulligan, and Melton sat down with * *ahead of the season 2 drop to break down how that pivotal fight scene came to be conceived, written, and eventually shot.

Cailee Spaeny and Charles Melton on 'Beef'.

Courtesy of Netflix

"As writers in the room, we sort of vomit out our intentions, but it's not until we put it on its feet with the actors that the real textures come alive," Lee says. "And we did a *lot* of rehearsals."

Mulligan echoes the sentiment. "It was a big, big development process" that took "months" of discussion and prep to get to "that whole first scene. It changed millions of times. It was madness," she says.

The first of the second season's eight episodes reaches a fever pitch early on when Josh leaves his wallet at the Monte Vista Port Country Club in Montecito, Calif. — an innocuous mistake that speedruns through the butterfly effect to ultimately calamitous ends. The lowly Ashley is tasked with returning his wallet, and the devoted Austin won't leave her side. As the pair inch toward the Martins' sprawling home (they live in a comparative shoebox, mind you), they oversee Josh and Lindsay engaged in a truly gruesome fight, with the four finally locking eyes as Lindsay cowers beneath her husband, his hand raised over her gripping a golf club.

"For Austin specifically in that moment, when they hear the domestic violence and they don't know what's going on, you kind of see his protector come in with Ashley," Melton says. He quotes his the "brilliant" Spaeny's line to him, "I go where you go," a line that "shows this stage of love that may be so relatable where you're just inseparable and you want to do everything with each other."

As for Josh and Lindsay, Lee jokes with Melton, "it's funny, I think you as Austin still see it as a little bit of a domestic violence incident, but from Josh and Lindsay's standpoint, they're probably like, 'Domestic violence? This was just a fight. This is all a heated debate.'"

'Beef' creator, stars preview season 2's 'brutal' rollercoaster ride, break down real fight inspiration

The 30 best shows to watch on Netflix right now

***Get your daily dose of entertainment news, celebrity updates, and what to watch with our ******EW Dispatch newsletter******.***

Indeed, the most gruesome part of Josh and Lindsay's altercation is what they say to each other, not what they do. Though in fairness, what they might have done was forestalled by Ashley and Austin's interruption. Lindsay demands to know if Josh will ever offer her a sexual option beyond "sexual deviant or celibacy." Josh claims he'd have sex with his wife if she looked and acted more like Mikaela Hoover's air-headed club-goer Ava. They both say they "f---ing hate" each other.

Crushingly, Lindsay breaks down and tells Josh, "You've wasted my whole life."

It was this line, added in the 11th hour, that unlocked the scene for Mulligan. "I kept on getting stuck on a line and we couldn't figure out why the scene wasn't working. I was saying something else to [Isaac] that was awful and [Lee] came over and said, 'I don't think you want to say that. I think you want to say, 'You've wasted my whole life.' And I was like, 'That's exactly it.' The scene worked the minute we got that line."

Lee remembers that moment from the shoot too, when "Carey just couldn't, even with all that prep, quite get there emotionally. Then I changed one line of dialogue to be more about how Josh wasted her life. Then she was like, 'Yep, that's it. Let's go.'"

Carey Mulligan as Lindsay Crane-Martin on 'Beef'.

Courtesy of Netflix

The near tragedy of domestic violence and the trauma of witnessing it quickly transform under the pressure of the inescapable force that pervades all of Lee's work — money. Josh and Lindsay have it. Ashley and Austin don't. Seems like they should be able to fix each other's problems, right?

For Melton, Austin's simple and seemingly unbreakable bond with Ashley begins to reveal its "codependent nature" after they witness the fight. "From there, you just watch the propulsion of one thing after the next happen, and the disintegration of the honeymoon phase. For Austin, it's the realization that the conviction he has in his identity is just a mask."

Lee previously told EW about the real-life fight overheard while on a walk in his neighborhood that inspired the scene. "When I was retelling that story to people," Lee found that his "younger peers were like, 'Oh my God, did you call the police? Is everything okay?' Whereas my-age -and-older peers were kind of like, 'I mean, who amongst us hasn't?'"

He describes that dichotomy as the season's "north star." But Isaac says it took a lot of work make those two halves whole. "It's a funny thing. We knew we had to get to this one moment. It was like figuring out how all the billiard balls hit each other to create that thing, but from a very organic place. It was a really fun puzzle to solve together."

*Beef *season 2 is currently streaming on Netflix.

Original Article on Source

Source: “EW Drama”